I saw someone shared a news story on Christmas day with the following headlines, “Star Wars fans and video game geeks ‘more likely to be narcissists’, study finds.” The first three paragraphs states
Those who take part in “geeky events” are more likely to have an “elevated grandiose” level of narcissism, according to a study conducted by the University of Georgia.
Psychologists examined the personality traits of those who turn to “geek culture”, developing a Geek Culture Engagement Scale and a Geek Identity Scale to help quantify the figures.
It was found that those who scored highly on both scales were more likely to narcissists.
Since we’re doing a current series on our blog on Christian worldview series on superheroes and comics I thought it was timely to post on this finding especially after reading the abstract to the actual study identified geek and geek culture relations to “obscure media” which include comics:
A geek is traditionally defined as an enthusiast who develops expertise on a topic through exceptional determination and devotion [1]. The word “geek” is used to describe not only enthusiasts in science, technology, and engineering but also especially devoted fans of media (i.e., “fandom geeks”). Here, we refer to geek culture as a subculture of enthusiasts that is traditionally associated with obscure media (Japanese animation, science fiction, video games, etc.). However, geek culture is becoming an increasingly mainstream influence on contemporary culture. Geek culture includes a range of activities such as role-playing games (e.g., Dungeons and Dragons), science fiction (e.g., Star Trek), comic books, and dressing in costumes (i.e., cosplay).
I think it is important to think carefully about the relationship of “geek” activities (video games, comics and Sci-Fi) and narcissism. We must be careful not to think that just because someone likes comics or have watched the latest Star Wars that this must mean that we can instantly judge an individual to be a narcissist. We don’t want to make the same logically fallacious jump as Job’s friend committed. Also the researchers also acknowledge more studies need to be done and that they have just started to lay the foundation for further studies.
Yet at the same time I think the correlation between the two from this study should make those who enjoy a certain form of entertainment to stop and engage in an honest soul-search to see if this might be describing them.
I don’t think there’s something intrinsic about comic books that makes someone a narcissist. I think the possible relationship between a “geek” and narcissism is suggested by what Jessica McCain, one of the study’s coauthor said to a writer with Science News: “Engaging in this fandom appears to be a way to feel powerful, to feel special in some way.” Of course, if someone wishes to be stand out and be different for one’s own self-worth then the heart motivation is something of concern in biblical counseling. Those involved with “geekdom” must ask themselves what is their heart motivation for them being a hardcore fan of X, Y or Z, and then evaluate the motivations biblically. For instance, it is possible that one pursue being a geek as a form of escapism. It’s a way of pursuing fantasies rather than face one’s bleak reality and the need for responsibility. Let me say again that I’m not attributing this to all geeks but merely giving an example of possible problematic motivation.
The study also states “In a sense, then, geek culture might be an additional outlet for narcissism but not the only one used by individuals.” So it’s not necessarily the activity of dressing up, reading comics or playing games that makes one narcissists but that “geekdom” might be a way of expressing one’s narcissism.
Besides asking the question of what is one’s heart motivation I think the other crucial diagnostic question is the importance of asking whether a person’s deepest satisfaction and pleasure will find its source from being self-identified and/or recognized by others as a “geek” or a “fan” of a particular source of entertainment. For the Christian, one’s identity that gives one a longing satisfaction and contentment would be being identified with Christ. That is, one’s union with Christ is now one’s identity. Anything else short of Christ as the foundation for one’s identity for the source of lasting satisfaction would be idolatry.
Another possible way of understanding the relationship between “geekdom” and Narcissism is to take a step back and see the larger social context of “geekdom.” I think “geekdom” is largely a phenomenon that enjoys its fullest Renaissance in a context of economic affluence since one must has the time and financial means to pursue entertainment, where one does not have to worry about being on survival mode. There is another interesting study mentioned in an article titled “Recessions take a lasting toll on narcissism.” As the article’s subtitle states, “Hard economic times dent young adults’ self-regard for decades.” Perhaps kids spoiled in a world where they are raised up in prosperity have a sense of self-entitlement that contribute to their narcissism. Thus, in pursuing “geeky” things, narcissism rears its’ ugly head. The sin of pride has a way of spilling into more than one’s domain in one’s life.
In summary, we have three pastoral diagnostic question concerning narcissism in one’s pursuit of media and entertainment that is often associated as “geeky.” I write this for the sake of the believers’ sanctification:
- Question of one’s motivation: “What is your heart motivation for being a fan of _________? What does God’s Word has to say about your motivation?”
- Question of one’s identity as basis of satisfaction: “Is the source of your deepest satisfaction and pleasure found in being self-identified and/or recognized by others as a “geek” or a “fan” of a particular source of entertainment, media, stories or characters?”
- Question of one’s wholistic life: “Do you detect narcissism in other areas of your life? Do others raise concern about any hints of you being a narcissist?”
If in the end we discover our own narcissism, how then do we cultivate humility as a virtue instead of the vice of pride? Consider and meditate on Christ and the Gospel, and the Incarnation. Start with Philippians 2.
Reblogged this on Talmidimblogging and commented:
Excellent piece!
Thanks for sharing this post of mine
You’re very welcome Pastor Jim!
From what I have seen in my 52 years of life is that the majority of those who engage in a type of role play that often accompanies a high zealousness for the fantasy are doing it more for escape than narcissism.
In a sense, I believe that many are searching for a new identity. In the same way that we became a new creation through Christ Jesus, many are themselves searching for a new identity. The only problem is that their new creation is a passing fad that will eventually fade out with time.
Oh well, this is just my thought with absolutely no foundation to back it up.
“many are themselves searching for a new identity. The only problem is that their new creation is a passing fad that will eventually fade out with time.”
I think that’s a well founded observation you made.
It is said that narcissists can’t discover their narcissism, they can’t allow themselves to see themselves as they truly, are. This keeps them from getting well or so the experts say. I think a narcissist is basically, an undeveloped person stuck in a child-like, self-centered view of self and others. Our culture promotes this lack of personal growth and development in many ways and while super-heroes may feed into a narcissistic need for a powerful false image of self, they can’t satisfy that need or help a dysfunctional person to become who they are intended to be. Only, Jesus can do that. I fully, believe that He can help a narcissist grow up to become the man or woman God designed them to be.
Pam I would say a big hearty amen. I do a lot of campus evangelism and over the years at my generation’s of guys that should be men but have become boy wonders and bearded Peter pans.
Yes, I am of the generation that raised them…but it took a village to mess them up. Parents make mistakes but even good parents can lose their kids to the world. The village is toxic to children and limits boys from becoming men. I think the social engineers believe we should be asexual and young men are emasculated in so many ways. It’s no wonder so many of them hide in mommy’s basement, dreaming of super heroes and fighting wars through video games, dreaming of being men while living in a world that demeans all that is manly. It’s so sad…we need to help boys feel good about being boys and help them look forward to being valued men.
Pam, I appreciated your analysis of the greater picture of this being a problem with society and not just with guys. Always appreciate your insight.
I also, appreciate yours.:0)
Interesting, I always thought it might be the opposite problem, thanks for the post.
Yeah it is counterintuitive to what most people think
[…] Geekdom (Starwars, comics, videogames), its correlation with narcissism and Christian sanctificatio… […]
[…] Geekdom (Starwars, comics, videogames), its correlation with narcissism and Christian sanctificatio… […]