Vern Poythress. Christian Interpretations of Genesis 1. Phillipsburg, NJ: Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing, September 20th, 2013. 32 pp.
4 out of 5
Purchase: Westminster | Amazon
This is another work in the “Christian Answers to Hard Questions” series published by Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing. Here the author Vern Poythress looks at how Christians should interpret the first chapter of Genesis. Although the author is a New Testament professor I think Poythress is more than capable to write on this subject given his expertise in hermeneutics, linguistics, science and theology.
The book begins with a survey of various views concerning Genesis 1. Poythress include lesser known views as well; for instance there is the Local-Creation Theory that sees the original creation being described in verse 1 while verse 2 describe devastation specifically in the Ancient Near East while verses 3 to 31 describe God’s re-creation locally of those devastated area. Prior to this I have not even heard of this view.
After laying out the various views Poythress then proceeded to discuss principles for evaluation of the various theories. I enjoyed his discussion about authority and in particular the issue of science and the Bible. I thought it was quite nuanced although I wished he could have talked more about hermeneutics.
The booklet then evaluated the theories in interpreting Genesis 1. Poythress organized the evaluation by grouping weaker theories together before he delivered longer discussions to more plausible theories. I really enjoyed Poythress pointing out problems with the weaker theories; he reasons and handled Genesis 1 well in this regards. However I do think in regards to the views he sees as more plausible he does not land strongly on any one conclusion. He does take a more critical view of Young Earth Creation but I think the issues he bring up does not conclusively rule it out which Poythress would also agree. I think some of the problems he pointed out for the Young Earth Creation view is not as problematic as he might think; for instance he pointed out the tree records indicates that trees have existed for 12,000-26,000 years. Taking these tree ring studies as true I think it does not rule out Young Earth Creation since various Young Earth Creationists hold to various duration of when the world has been around. Moreover Poythress has not scratched the essence of the literal six day creation doctrine that is the essence of the Young Earth Creationist’s position. I was also disappointed that Poythress didn’t handle the Hebrew grammatical and syntactical argument from Genesis 1 from the observation of ordinal versus cardinal Hebrew numbers with the word “yom” (day).
Even if one disagrees with this booklet I think the charitable and informed way that the author wrote this makes it beneficial.
Reblogged this on Talmidimblogging.
Vincent thank you for this reblog, I hope you are doing well brother!
You’re very welcome Pastor Jim, doing good… Surgeon appointment on December 4th
Thanks for the review. I would be interested in the author’s comparisons of the different theories.
Here’s a link to the PDF: https://veritasdomain.wordpress.com/2013/09/17/free-on-pdf-christian-interpretations-of-genesis-1-by-vern-poythress/
Thanks! I just printed it out at work. Good reading one night during this long weekend!
I am YEC, which is not popular in some circles but is biblical.
That being said, I don’t think people who are not YEC are condemned.
Your stance is my stance. I personally just can’t see how the grammar could be avoided as I pointed out in my post. Also I am less dogmatic concerning how old the earth is versus the belief that creation is completed after 6 days. But I haven’t followed creationism literature as much as I do other areas of theology and apologetics. What’s some of your favorite authors, scientists and ministries?
To me the biggest issue is the handling of scripture. To accommodate loooooong ages, one has to re-define the text, the genre or both. YEC is the only view that cohesively handle all of the evidence and proper interpretation of scripture.
Some of my favorite authors are:
Marvin Lubenow (Bones of Contention) – fossils
Jason Lisle (The Ultimate Proof of Creation) – Transcendental Argument
ProofThatGodExists.org – Not specifically YEC, but comes to the conclusion from scripture.
Creation.com
TheCreationClub.com
crev.info
I can’t say I have a favorite scientist but as far as authors go, I like the usual saspects; Lewis, Tozer, Packer…I also like fiction so Koonz, Tolkien, Lee Child…
Ministries is a tougher one because I am most fond of local ministries I know and/or volunteer with. One of those, in particular, does a lot of work with homeless and the materially poor and downtrodden.
Reblogged this on Averagechristiannet and commented:
Reposted review from Domain for Truth on a new book examining 4 views of how to interpret Genesis 1
[…] « Review: Christian Interpretations of Genesis 1 […]
I dont profess to be a minister..I do however share my witnessing with others.All Glory be God’s