A weekend leisure reading review…because sometimes Pastors also need a break from heavy theological reading!
Rick Beyer. Rivals Unto Death: Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr New York, NY: Hachette Book Group, February 21st 2017. 224.
5 out of 5
Purchase: Amazon
Reading this book made me realize that the current heated American political scene during election is nothing new, that it has had its crazy moments and its up and downs. This book is about the animosity and competition between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr which most American remember with the duel between these two men that were involved with American politics that result in the death of one after the duel. But rather than focus only on the duel the book looks at both men’s lives and the comparison and contrast between the two of them and how their lives culminated to that unfortunate duel.
I thought the author did a good job comparing and contrasting Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr. This book is a look at not only the biographical details of both men but also how their paths cross pathed or orbited near one another over the decades. I really enjoyed learning about both men’s upbringing and also their military career during the War of Independence. I thought it was interesting to see how both men were similar in how they were driven, talented and energetic both as officers in the Contintental Army and later in their New York law practice. Yet there were differences between them including their deposition and also how people perceived them.
Overall in my opinion the author did an excellent job in giving us facts and attempted to be fair. There was a sense that later in their politics the book gives you the details of both men’s concerns with the political direction of the country. Yet their concern seem to be the reaction of coming to the opposite conclusion of their upbringing: Alexander Hamilton who grew up poor was concerned about the tyranny of the masses while Aaron Burr who grew up in an affluent household was suspicious of the few rich elites in the political process. The book goes over the scandals of both men while also putting the over the top rhetoric of the political discourse in the context of that being how it was during their time. Sadly with many factors being set it led us to an event where because of honor Hamilton and Burr faced each other in a duel and one would be killed. In one of history’s dispute of what happened that day with the duel which debate linger to today, Hamilton was killed and Burr ended up being quite hated.
Fascinating read and it lead me to put current American politics in perspective and to also pray that our country’s election process would not undermine the republic.
Thanks for the interesting review! This is definitely a book I would enjoy reading. I’ve always been intrigued by the Hamilton-Burr conflict and dual. Interesting how each man was suspicious of the social group they were rooted in.
It fascinated me these two men; I think you will enjoy it especially since part of theIr stories takes place in New York! I didn’t know that the New York Post was originated by Alexander Hamilton, did you know that?
Wow NY Post came from Hamilton? Incredible how long NYP has been around
Nope, I didn’t know about Hamilton and the NY Post. Thanks for the interesting trivia!
Thank you for your review Jim! While reading, almost all sentences made me recall certain songs and lines from the Hamilton Musical. In the song, The Room Where it Happens, Hamilton asked Burr what does he stand for, and for me that spells the difference between them too.
Did you watch the Musical more than once or do you have a good memory?
Actually, I watched musical scores or selected songs from Youtube especially when doing chores and one of those musicals is Hamilton (just the top 10 best). I still have to watch the entire musical in Disney+ maybe early next month. You can watch some song covers in Youtube. What I like is 1) My Shot, 2) You’ll be back, 3) Story of tonight, 4) the Room Where it Happens, 5) Yorktown, 6) story of tonight reprise, 7) Satisfied, 8) Burn, 9) intro song/Alexander Hamilton, and 10) helpless. Check their covers on Youtube, Jim.
I don’t know a lot in history but I do know Aaron Burr shot Alexander Hamilton
Thank you. I was unaware of the duel.
It can be easily forgotten with so much in history. Hope you have a blessed Lord’s Day Maw Maw! Stay warm and stay safe!
To you also. Sunny and 85 here. The clean up of Laura will take several months.
That was such a tragic scene in our history.
That was a tragedy; thank you also for your comments and you wishing congratulations with blog’s 14th year anniversary. Has it been 8 plus years for you yourself?
Not sure, lol. I’ll have to check to be sure, but it probably is.
The rivalry between Hamilton and Burr fascinated me years ago. While I haven’t read much about it for some time, I can appreciate the author’s efforts to be unbiased and objective.
My coder is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on various websites for about a year and am concerned about switching to another platform. I have heard very good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress posts into it? Any kind of help would be really appreciated!
Wow that’s a crazy time, our politics hopefully won’t be so crazy and murderous!
I got Amazon gift cards, was wondering if I should buy this book that I’ve had someone tell me about and your review sealed the deal, thanks!
Aaron Burr makes me think of those Got Milk commercials
Alexander Hamilton, what a character.
I am hungering to know more about him after the musical!
Great Gift. You should read about Jackson disagreeing with Others
I was curious if you ever considered turning this blog into a history site?