Over the years the percentage of my reading on ebooks have increased though I still try to read primarily physical books.
Yet I try to read the Bible as much as possible through the medium of a hardcopy physical book.
I’m not legalistic about it but I thought there’s advantages to reading in general with physical books; and that has implications for why we want to read from a physical book form Bible.
I found this interesting article from Book Riot that says:
Before the early ’90s, studies, according to The Scientific American, “concluded that people read slower, less accurately and less comprehensively on screens than on paper.”
Later studies back this up. A study on kids’ enjoyment when they read ebooks vs physical books report “children showed a preference for print” despite the allure of a screen. Parents, too, reported their children “paid more attention” to a print book. A Norwegian study of 10th graders revealed those who read paperbacks scored higher on post-reading questionnaires than those who read on computer screens, both with informational and narrative texts.
…
A 2014 study found adults who read a mystery in paper form had “superior retention” of the story in comparison to those who read it on Kindle. Psychologist Kate Garland’s “Do E-Books Make it Harder to Remember What You Just Read?” reported subjects needing to read something multiple times before understanding it to the same degree as those reading in print. Stavanger University in Norway conducted a study in which 50 people read the same short story, half on a Kindle and half in print. They came to the conclusion that “paper readers did report higher on measures having to do with empathy and transportation and immersion, and narrative coherence, than iPad readers.”
Most notable was the lack of being able to piece together the plot of the novel. According to PRI, “humans use different parts of the brain when reading from a piece of paper or from a screen…the more you read on screens, the more your mind shifts towards “non-linear” reading — a practice that involves things like skimming a screen or having your eyes dart around a web page.” The New York Times reports, “people read more slowly on screen, by as much as 20–30 percent.”
I also notice that when I read from a physical Bible I have better memory of returning to a specific passage because of my memory of where it is in the Bible, the location its found on a page, etc.
Furthermore I’m less distracted with things compared to reading on a laptop or other electronic devices.
What other advantages you can think of with physical Bibles?
It’s easier for me to make notes in physical copies of Bibles and books rather than trying to highlight electronically. I am thankful for electronic books when I travel, but I know I retain info far better with a print copy than an electronic copy!
Same sister! I too find it easier to highlight from physical copies; in addition I read on some apps for ebooks though my local library and this one app is horrible for highlighting since pages its hard to highlight to the next page without it going beserk and moving to multiple pages that I suddenly highlighted because of the way the app works. I do like e books for traveling though so its less obvious than say I bring a whole bunch of big books on theology and the Bible! Good point! Got your powerpoint presentation and praying for the youth group soon! Big thank you again
Good post, thanks for sharing. Really interesting topic. I primarily use an electronic bible now, as due to poor eyesight I can enlarge the text or even have it read to me. I agree though, it’s an entirely different skill to use an electronic device over a hardcopy. Actually, I would encourage people to listen to an audio Bible where they can, not as a replacement for reading, but in addition to. It could be helpful.
I agree with you with the benefits of eBible that you mentioned and audio Bibles! It helps redeems the time with audio Bibles IMO. Thanks Andy for sharing that!
In a physical book you can write your own notes right on the page you read! That is better than a separate file on electronics. It’s more personal. I am now looking for your book, “Highlights Of My Favorites!” Apologetics!
Thanks for sharing that! I imagine your posts flows fro your physical notes from your Bible reading?? Far too kind and gracious with your encouraging comment =)
I think it would be great to read a book you have authored my friend! 👊🏼
I retain more reading the physical Bible and not hard on my eyes like electronic devices letting me know I have been online too long.
Same here! Thanks for sharing that Tangie, I identify with that!
You can do it! I believe in you!
I know I can retain more in a physical book, because I can relate important data that I’d highlighted (e.g.) to either right or left hand page.
And viewing anything on a screen for long durations can negatively affect the eyes–at least mine.
Also, it’s my understanding–and I could be wrong on this–that ‘books’ purchased for a particular device (say, Kindle) are not actually ‘owned’ by the purchaser. Should someone (publisher) decide to remove a particular book, said book will disappear from device. Can anyone refute or confirm?
There is a risk but you can always download the kindle files and use technology to get access to them. You purchased them.
Hey Craig,
In an article I’ll link to: “When you buy an ebook from Amazon, it’s yours, right? Technically speaking, Amazon is merely licensing the book to you. And the company can, seemingly on a whim, close your account and delete all your books.
This isn’t likely to happen, but it gives me pause. Indeed, it makes me want to back up the books I bought and paid for, just in case. What’s more, if I ever decide I want to read those books using, say, another reader (be it an app or device), I’d like the option of converting them to another format. Both options require the removal of Amazon’s DRM — the digital lock the company puts on its books to prevent unauthorized sharing.
I have no intention of sharing. I simply want to exercise my fair-use rights. Luckily, it’s possible to remove Amazon’s DRM (at your own risk, of course) using free book manager Calibre and a couple plug-ins.”
https://www.pcworld.com/article/456892/convert-a-kindle-ebook-to-a-different-format.html
Here is another article:
https://pdf.wondershare.com/how-to/convert-kindle-to-pdf.html
This article has good step-by-step process on how to download your kindle books from Amazon to your computer.
https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/how-to-convert-kindle-to-pdf/
ZAMZAR is another converter.
https://www.zamzar.com
This short YouTube video gives an overview of Calibre.
NaturalReader is a way to turn an eBook into an audiobook.
https://www.howtogeek.com/753238/how-to-turn-any-ebook-into-an-audiobook/
Read up on it. Step 1 – would be to get comfortable downloading your eBooks to your PC or Mac.
Step 2- Read up on these articles and others you find.
Step 3 – Sounds like there are a few tech people who read and participate on the blog so you can reach out for advice.
Step 4 – just go for it and have some fun! 😀
I don’t know of any case where books disappeared but the technology is definitely there for them to do that; which should be cautious for us Christians. I also sometimes am hestitant of books purchased through Amazon kindle directly (as opposed to pdf, etc) since when I go teach overseas sometimes in some countries Amazon blocks me from downloading my own kindle books that I already purchased since I’m not in Contintental North America or the West. When I go overseas I try to already have all my kindle books downlaoded but then when I’m overseas sometimes people ask me questions and I have to go back to books I already read that I didn’t plan to have all downloaded on my device. I am digressing far off now but this something for those doing ministry should keep in mind for the future what you said and also presently right now for certain countries
Glory to God He has deposited a love for Him and His Word in our hearts. I love the many ways we have access to Holy Scripture and I would always want to have and utilize a physical Bible.
For those who like audio, you can check out the audio Bible reading on Berean Crossroads.
Soli Dei Gloria
Thanks for sharing that! There’s definitely a place for audio Bibles! Blessings to you Koineroad!
really good points, Jim. And everything above confirms my own experience.
Thanks for giving your feedback and input with this; makes me love my physical Bible more
My very first time reading the Bible was on Kindle 😁 But now I also have a physical copy, and I do enjoy it! I love highlighting it (with a colored pencil is best for thin pages). However, I still read my Kindle one in bed at night, because I don’t have to turn the light on. Interesting post! I just hope people read God’s Word, no matter in what form 🥰
Amen whatever the format I just hope people read the Bible sister! Have a blessed Saturday!
I have never been able to read an eBook all the way through and I spend a lot of money each month on second hand books but I changed churches a little over a year ago and moved from NIV to ESV bible. Now I would not be without my mini iPad and the Olive Tree app. I always read in split screen mode with text and study notes showing. You can sync the screens to scroll together and there are five highlighting colours. You can even refer to study notes by other authors, search other texts and find key word references.
Thanks for sharing your own reading experience! I love the way you describe how you study the Word of God!
Interesting topic brother. The point, I think, is that is important to read and study God’s word.
I have the opposite experience. I am exclusively an eBook reader. I started the transition many years ago as traveled a lot and found it easier to have my whole library with me rather than the one or two books I could carry on a plane.
I study with Logos software and find it invaluable. It has a wonderful downloadable client, a great iPhone app and a Web version. They all synch seamlessly. I use 4 – 5 main translations at any time (but can use more). I have hundreds of commentaries available instantly. When I study a passage, the relevant commentaries are in a separate panel at the place where I am studying. I highlight a word in English, and it brings up 3 or 4 Greek translations (Strongs or Louw Nida is what I use primarily). I press a button and my interlinear appears. My note taking is enhanced with no limits imposed by limited physical space on a small side column of a page. When I highlight items, I have many highlighter colors to choose from instantly. I have over a thousand resources I have purchased over the years, all indexed and available always as I study. I could write on for pages about the advantages. I should write a post. 😁😂
I appreciate Kindle and the technology has radically improved. I no longer have a Kindle reader. I use it on my laptop and iPhone. It synchronizes so I am always on the right page. Highlighting is enhanced as is note taking. I find though, that most of reading is of a religious nature, the books I would normally read from Kindle are also available in Logos and I purchase them there.
Thanks for the opportunity to weigh in.
Shalom!
Brother you should have this as a post. I would link to it too as a balance to my post. Let me know when this becomes a post!!!
I agree that Logos is invaluable!!!!!!
I LOVE my Kindle ebook reader! But I am unfamiliar with logos. I’m going to have to look into that.
Logos is a Bible software; hope to get it sometime this year for myself
It is neat reading how different people read and study GOd’s Word on here in the comments
Yes it is! There’s something to learn about learning from others!!
Nice to see differing opinions and charity
Amen!
This is an excellent idea for a post. I’ve had a Kindle for many years. It took me a long time, but I think I’m at the point where I might slightly prefer ebook to hardcopy. Of the 26 books I read last year, 12 were ebook. I bought a giant print hardcopy ESV Bible last year for my “golden years,” but I continue to read my three daily chapters from the ESV app on my iPhone. For a long time, I used to read along with the audio option, but found I actually focus better if I turn off the audio.
Wow thanks for sharing how you read the Bible. When you have it on ESV do you have the fonts larger than the ESV physical Bible?
I have the font set at “medium,” so a bit larger than standard/small hard copy Bible font. I don’t need Giant font as of yet, but it is very easy to read. Standard font is now too small for me.
[…] Reading a Physical Bible versus electronically — The Domain for Truth […]
I can write on physical bibles. I use something similar Jonathan Edwards’ note-taking system.
Have you done a post on Edwards’ system? I don’t remember
Not yet brother.
Physical books, especially Bibles, feel nice to hold. I also enjoy sitting on a park bench while reading a physical book; my phone is just too small. However, if I want to research something I am glad to have a computer nearby.
Amen! Thanks for describing your reading and studying habit, I pray it encourage someone reading this to study God’s Word!
What a wonderful discussion in the comments! For meditation and study and prayer, I prefer my hard copy Bible. Less distractions. But all these proliferating aids in reading and studying the Word is the Lord’s doing during a time when Christians are the most persecuted religious group worldwide.
Thanks for sharing that Dora! I feel the same as you do and I share the same preference as you do too! Amen!
Interesting observations. Jim. I use both because there are advantages to both physical reading and electronic reading, especially on the electronic side when it comes to quick referencing and access to associated data. I’ve always been able to score very high in comprehension and this ability I possess I attribute to attention to detail which can often be over looked via electronic means. In my early years of studying God’s Word I relied heavily on underlining and highlighting pertinent Scriptures as a means of increasing my retention of important aspects I wanted to remember and this method still produces the most beneficial retention in my estimation. In my university days I ran across a study which indicated the mere act of underling and highlighting material one read significantly increased ones retention of the material being studied and I personally found this to be true, at least for me. I also learned to read out loud the portions I was underlining as an additional retention method. My comprehension also increases when I study audio by obtaining a transcript and going over it again if possible. Senior leadership courses and instructor courses I was required to take in the military, also produced high retention results with high scores or marks, because of my continued use of underlining and highlighting. I’ve used both physical and electronic reading through the last few decades but I still rely on the physical when I want to do a deep dive into Scripture on a particular subject. I’ve gone through a number of physical Bibles through the years and I purchased a new hard copy study edition a couple of years ago, which I am still going through, painstakingly slow, with underlining and color code highlighting indicating levels of relative importance, which continues to produce unexpected dividends. In my personal observations, both methods produce unique benefits and neither should be overlooked. And, I still find that there is something special about placing your physical hands on God’s physical Word. It’s just not the same when you reach out and touch a screen. I can’t really explain it, but I just find that there is. Blessings!
Wow Bruce thank you for sharing that with insights of how you study and learn. I too find highlighting and underlinining and writing physical notes reinforce memory retention than just highlighting on a device; great stuff Bruce! This comment is worth making into a post
Possibly so, I just know what works for me. Everyone has their own preferences on how to study, as long as one is studying God’s Holy Word, it’s all good!
I don’t know if I can think of any advantages a real book has over an ebook, but I like to hold books, mark them up, put notes in them, highlight parts, and underline sentences.
I can place them on my bookshelves, and when I read them again, all those notes and highlighted parts are still there.
Those things are things I like about real physical books!
[…] Reading a Physical Bible versus electronically — The Domain for Truth […]
1. My practice is to buy ebooks for most books, but then buy physical books for books I know I want to read and re-read. That of course includes the Bible, the book of books! 🙂
2. I’m a bibliophile (but hopefully not a snob!) so I even look into beautifully designed albeit expensive books from places like the Folio Society, Schuyler Bibles (e.g. Schuyler Treveris ESV), etc.
3. I have an older brother in Christ who tells me that it’s getting harder for him to read small font in physical books so he prefers to read virtually everything he can on his Kindle ebook reader because he can adjust the font size to whatever he prefers. I think that’s a good reason for some people to prefer ebooks.
Well thought out. I am not against e-books totally but of your 3 points, its the last one that makes me think about how I might read more E-books as I get older. You should blog this at the big blog!
I read ebooks only for fiction. I love reading Physical books. I love the smell and feel of my mother’s KJV Bible that I read in large print. She has marked many passages and so have I.
Wow I hope you can pass your mother’s Bible to a future generation!
I will.:)
Just try underlining on an e-book reader…
Personally, I trade off. There are some Bibles that are expensive, but I can get them for much less in electronic versions (I don’t use study Bibles). Studies or not, it just feels better to have a physical book. By the way, I read from a different version each month for various reasons.
Thanks for sharing that. That’s neat you read different Bible versions regularly Bob
I’ll take my books any way I can get them, on my phone through Aubible, on my computer through the Bible apps, but there’s nothing like sitting and holding a physical book in your hands and turning each page with anticipation for what’s on the next, and the next, and then the final pages… oh how sweet the feel of that paper under my fingertips, the smell of the paper and the ink. There’s no substitute.
Big amen!!
I like taking sermon notes on my iPad, and I love having the Bible with me wherever I go on my phone. But I do see advantages to using a paper version. I’m just too lazy to get reading glasses, which I’d need if I read the traditional way!
P.S. Keep up the great work on your blog! I always read it but haven’t done much commenting on any blogs lately. I don’t know how you keep up with all you do, but the content is great and challenging. Blessings.
Thanks for sharing! This has been so informative to hear people’s method of reading. Thanks also for the encouragement I hope you are doing well
Brother!
Give me a physical book any day!
I’m with ya!
I much prefer reading from my hardbound (physical) Bible. When I open it daily to read, I feel the invitation from the worn pages to continue my own journey with God’s Word.
Love your last sentence!
Just finished reading about macular degeneration and blue light from phone, laptop and PC screens.
Our receptors cannot be repaired or restored. All damage is permant. going blind from reading about the light of the world?
Good loint. I am online a lot and wear UV protection glasses but I need to be careful hence my preference for physical Bibles
Yes yes, there’s less distractions with the physical bible. I find myself writing more when I use the physical compare to when I’m using the phone.
Thanks for sharing that Jen! My reasoning with reading physical Bible is the same as yours as stated here
well for me reading physical books is much harder bc i finger zoom a lot and cut and paste. I don’t like buying books bc once I have read them then there is a storage problem so i leave the book somewhere
you can do so much more with electronic text
You bring up good points Ray! Blessings to you thanks for the interactions on Mewe
[…] Reading a Physical Bible versus electronically […]
Well done. I love YouVersion, but I found that nothing will ever replace (my time with God) having a Bible, journal, and some sort of companion text.
[…] Reading a Physical Bible versus electronically […]
I agree with the getting lost part. In 2020 I listened to the Breathe Bible (Holman CSB, with Kevin Sorbo as God and a lot of others, Wintley Phipps as Peter) on my way to Tennessee to pick up my wife (babysitting and then COVID lockdown leading to us being separated for months). I was deeply moved by what I was hearing at the time, but I could not remember if it was 1 and 2 Peter or 1, 2, and 3 John. In doing Bible studies of all those books, I still can’t remember what had moved me, other than a total immersion in vocalized Scripture for about 11 straight hours of driving (stopping for fueling and meals).
Wow thanks for sharing that. That must have also been a trying time for you too which can effect what we remember…
It was a trying time. I went down before all the lockdown restrictions were lifted. My wife was sounding off (mentally and physically). It was about three months later that she started kidney dialysis. It is hard to put a finger on the inspirations from the epistles, but the health events are sharp memories. And as usual, I find comfort and strength when writing.